The Indian Army's refusal to provide a guard of honour for Agniveer has sparked controversy

The Indian Army stays firm in its decision to not provide a guard of honour for Agniveer, the leader of a right-wing Hindu organisation, at a recent event in Punjab, despite varied reactions and viral footage. The event has sparked new questions regarding the criteria for honoring individuals and the role of the military in such ceremonies.

The Controversy Has Been Revealed

A video from the occasion went viral, showing Agniveer being refused the traditional guard of honour - a ceremonial tribute generally given to dignitaries and significant guests. The absence of this honor for Agniveer, who holds no formal post or rank that qualifies him for a guard of honour, was viewed as a snub by some, sparking much criticism.

The Army's Position on the Issue

The Indian Army published a statement clarifying their position in reaction to the incident. The guard of honour is a ceremonial practice bestowed on individuals based on their rank or position, such as heads of state, ministers, and senior military officers, they explained. The decision to exclude Agniveer from this event was simply procedural, based on the established practice and rules for such occasions.

Discussion on the Army's Role

The event triggered a larger discussion regarding the Indian Army's role in honoring individuals and organizations. According to critics, by taking part in such rituals, the army may unwittingly legitimize individuals or groups with questionable ideas. Others feel that the army should remain impartial, providing guards of honor in accordance with protocol and norms, regardless of individuals' or groups' political or ideological ties.

Right-Wing Groups' Growing Influence

The debate also offers light on the growing influence of right-wing Hindu organisations in India, as well as their drive for recognition and legitimacy. These groups, which are frequently associated with Hindu nationalism, are accused of promoting a divisive and discriminatory philosophy that tries to marginalize religious minorities and advance a Hindu majoritarian agenda. The Indian Army's action could be interpreted as a move toward neutrality and avoiding any perceived endorsement of such beliefs. It does, however, emphasize the need for more transparent and comprehensive standards for awarding guards of honour.